Evangelicals and Abortion

This short work steers Christians towards a pro-life position that is firm, compassionate, and intelligent. J. Cameron Fraser’s work divides into three parts: Historical, Theological, and Practical. The focus is USA-centric, but every chapter remains pertinent for the UK reader.

Fraser’s historical survey is deep, enlightening, and sobering. Here evangelicals rediscover their history. It will surprise some to learn that only 50 years ago most evangelicals did not take a firmly pro-life stance, something more associated with Catholics and the political left. Understanding the reasons for the evangelical opinion shift – both social and theological reasons – is a rewarding exercise.

Perhaps the book’s chief value is in providing the hard evidence that takes us beyond the factoids and slogans. The extent of post-abortion regret, the holocaust comparison, the promotion of adoption over abortion: these are not simple matters, and Fraser treats them with balance and care. Given the polarising nature of his subject, his commitment to fairness is almost courageous.

Readers will have their own conclusions about the final chapter. Fraser argues that the overturning of Roe v. Wade is not an automatic victory. Indeed, until Christians tackle the broader social problems, it may even have unintended consequences. But politically zealous readers should resist the urge to caricature here. In prioritising ‘mercy ministries’, Fraser is not deeming all political action futile. And, given that Fraser has played his own part in rallying evangelicals to the pro-life cause, he of all people is qualified to express reservations.

This book will make some readers uncomfortable in places. But that will just have to be. Maturity means learning to stomach difficult truths, and Fraser appears to have almost acquired a taste for them. Readers will be grateful for their enlarged, more nuanced understanding, and deeper compassion for both mother and unborn child.

Michael Taylor 

Newcastle upon Tyne